How many “Wise Men” were at the manger, and when did they arrive? Christmas Eve? Christmas Day? Perhaps sometime later (Epiphany or even later than that?). What really was the
Bethlehem “star”: perhaps a comet (like the current “Christmas comet Lovejoy” seen here). Or, maybe an astronomical conjunction of planets, combined with an astrological “reading” of meaning and prophecy. And, who got it right, Matthew’s account or Luke’s: did the Holy Family flee to Egypt, awaiting Herod’s death and a safe return some years after Jesus’ birth, or did they simply “settle down” to life in Nazareth and take part in having Jesus grow up like any other kid from that “backwater” town (Nazareth’s reputation: “can anything good come out of Nazareth?”–John 1:46).
Speculation about these things have circulated for centuries. Both the faithful and those who doubt–the genuinely concerned and even the “fringe” of the faithful and the skeptic, respectfully– mull over the Christian claims and speculations about the Incarnation. They are often used as platforms for supporting or debunking their own opinions. I find this all fascinating, and good fun, but not worth getting into what I call “theological rock fights” about what inevitably comes down to be side-shows to the main attraction of faith.
We may find it humbling to be reminded that God did all this “Jesus business” without anyone’s permission. Frankly, what we do with the angel’s announcement to the shepherds, “unto you (all) is born this day…”, is the essential question to respond to.
It is the “plural you” that first bids a response from us. And then comes the “individual you” that each one of us has to deal with. Lutherans generally don’t buy into the “personal Lord and Savior” appeal of “decision theology” that other evangelicals champion. Although, Luther himself made a pretty big deal about the “gurgling babe” born “for you,” the Bethlehem child apprehended by each believer’s heart as a life-saving encounter.
Ah well….Perhaps it is enough and proper to simply sit and wonder for a day or two that “unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given.” –Isaiah 9:6 
Merry Christmas to all. Really. Now and always.





